Russell Kirk's Defense of the American Tradition
Requires Subscription Full Article


Russell Kirk
Patrick Deneen
American constitutionalism

How to Cite

Russell Kirk’s Defense of the American Tradition: Liberalism and Reconstitution. (2021). The Political Science Reviewer, 45(2), 507-544.


Russell Kirk's The Roots of American Order (1974) and Patrick J. Deneen's Why Liberalism Failed (2018) present competing views of the American tradition. The division is due largely to different views of John Locke’s influence on American constitutional formation. Deneen rejects the possibility that the American order is derived from both liberal and pre-liberal influences. Kirk, by contrast, finds continuity between the older Western and American traditions. This article investigates how competing visions of technology and virtue in these two thinkers speaks to the origin and future of liberalism in the American political order.

Requires Subscription Full Article