Keywords
Carl Schmitt
political theology
revelation
sovereignty
modernity
liberalism
love
How to Cite
Abstract
This article demonstrates how Hans Urs von Balthasar’s theology of love, which he claims is the only “credible” alternative to older theological conceptions whose organizing principles are no longer plausible justifications for belief, cannot operate as a political theology. This impossibility raises questions of credibility for the field of political theology as a whole. To demonstrate this challenge, the article compares Balthasar’s theology to three major concepts of political theology: the friend-enemy distinction, sovereignty, and the totality of the political. The article concludes by arguing that the only possible, credible approaches to political theology would be limited ones—ones which do not claim to combine or identify politics with theology, which do not claim to explain the whole of reality via politics, and which are aware of and content within the proper limits of this methodology.
Similar Articles
- Lee Trepanier, Political Theology in the Twenty-first Century , The Political Science Reviewer: Vol. 46 No. 1 (2022): Symposium on Political Theology
- Sandrine Baume, Emancipation from the Legal Order , The Political Science Reviewer: Vol. 46 No. 1 (2022): Symposium on Political Theology
- Grant Havers, Leo Strauss on Nazism , The Political Science Reviewer: Vol. 42 No. 1 (2018): Symposium: Philosophy in Weimar Germany
- J. David Franks, Apocalypse of Reality , The Political Science Reviewer: Vol. 46 No. 1 (2022): Symposium on Political Theology
- Samuel Garrett Zeitlin, Order and Command , The Political Science Reviewer: Vol. 47 No. 1 (2023): Political Theory and Economics, and other Essays
- Nathan Pinkoski, Why Alasdair MacIntyre is not a Conservative Post-Liberal , The Political Science Reviewer: Vol. 43 No. 2 (2019): Symposium: The Missouri Compromise at 200
- Eduardo Schmidt Passos, Carl Schmitt’s Political Theory during the Third Reich , The Political Science Reviewer: Vol. 42 No. 1 (2018): Symposium: Philosophy in Weimar Germany
- Daniel J. Mahoney, With Reason Attentive to Grace , The Political Science Reviewer: Vol. 46 No. 1 (2022): Symposium on Political Theology
- Steven Waldorf, Nature, Grace, and "the Drama of Atheist Humanism” , The Political Science Reviewer: Vol. 46 No. 1 (2022): Symposium on Political Theology
- Gregory M. Collins, Eric Voegelin on the Constitutional and Metaphysical Foundations of Property Rights in U.S. Supreme Court Jurisprudence , The Political Science Reviewer: Vol. 47 No. 1 (2023): Political Theory and Economics, and other Essays
You may also start an advanced similarity search for this article.
Most read articles by the same author(s)
- Paul H Lewis, Practical Reasoning as Personal Knowing , The Political Science Reviewer: Vol. 37 (2008): Symposium: The Life and Work of Michael Polanyi
- Larry Arnhart, The Deliberative Rhetoric of The Federalist , The Political Science Reviewer: Vol. 19 (1990): Symposium: <em>The Federalist</em>
- Wilfred McClay, Thoughts on Teresa Bejan's Mere Civility , The Political Science Reviewer: Vol. 42 No. 2 (2018): Symposium: The Political Thought of Robert Nisbet
- Charlotta Stern, Daniel B Klein, Political Scientists’ Policy Views and Voting , The Political Science Reviewer: Vol. 35 (2006): Symposia on Edmund Burke and on Russell Kirk’s <em>The Conservative Mind</em>
- Lee Trepanier, War, Progress, and Sociology in the Age of Ideology , The Political Science Reviewer: Vol. 36 (2007): A Symposium on Leo Strauss and His Students
- Stephen A McKnight, The Legitimacy of the Modern Age , The Political Science Reviewer: Vol. 19 (1990): Symposium: <em>The Federalist</em>
- Michael Franz, Eric Voegelin’s The Ecumenic Age , The Political Science Reviewer: Vol. 27 (1998): Eric Voegelin’s <em>The Ecumenic Age</em>: A Symposium
- Peter Schotten, Paul Freund’s Constitution , The Political Science Reviewer: Vol. 14 (1984): Reviews
- Joseph Pappin, Edmund Burke’s Progeny , The Political Science Reviewer: Vol. 35 (2006): Symposia on Edmund Burke and on Russell Kirk’s <em>The Conservative Mind</em>
- Manfred Henningsen, The Emerging Universalism of Eric Voegelin , The Political Science Reviewer: Vol. 27 (1998): Eric Voegelin’s <em>The Ecumenic Age</em>: A Symposium