Keywords
Citizenship
Political Theory
Political Thought
Indigenous Political Thought
How to Cite
Abstract
There is a tension between indigenous and American views of the citizen, a tension permeating civic discourse and policy making. While previous work has couched this tension in racial prejudice and greed, we posit an antecedent factor: regime. To demonstrate this, we use Aristotelian thought to create a new interpretive framework to analyze competing claims of citizenship and the good life. Focusing on the tension between the Cherokee Nation and the United States in the late 18th Century, we find the latter's liberal views of citizenship at odds with the former's non-liberal views. This research aims to restore debates surrounding questions of the good life and apply it to understanding conflicts between regimes.
Similar Articles
- Sarah Gustafson, Opening the American Heart , The Political Science Reviewer: Vol. 47 No. 2 (2023): The Future Before Us: Early Career Women in Political Theory and Constitutional Studies
- Max Smith, Machiavelli's Democratic Civil Religion in the Discourses on Livy , The Political Science Reviewer: Vol. 48 No. 1 (2024): Essays
- Bernat Torres Morales, Josep Monserrat Molas, The Significance of Plato’s Philebus in the Philosophy of Eric Voegelin , The Political Science Reviewer: Vol. 41 No. 1 (2017): Symposium: Eric Voegelin and the Ancients
- Barry Cooper, Glenn Hughes, S.F. McGuire, Carol Cooper, Tilo Schabert, Author Meets Critics: Tilo Schabert's The Figure of Modernity: On the Irregularity of an Epoch , The Political Science Reviewer: Vol. 45 No. 2 (2021): Symposium: Russell Kirk in the 21st Century
- Zachary K. German, The Visible Hands of Statesmanship , The Political Science Reviewer: Vol. 47 No. 1 (2023): Political Theory and Economics, and other Essays
- Brianne Wolf, Tocqueville and the Moral Economy of Bankruptcy in Nineteenth-Century America , The Political Science Reviewer: Vol. 47 No. 2 (2023): The Future Before Us: Early Career Women in Political Theory and Constitutional Studies
- John Boersma, Adam Smith’s Eulogy for Self-Command , The Political Science Reviewer: Vol. 47 No. 1 (2023): Political Theory and Economics, and other Essays
- Scott P Segrest, Muhammad Iqbal's Reconstructed Islam , The Political Science Reviewer: Vol. 46 No. 1 (2022): Symposium on Political Theology
- V Bradley Lewis, Gerhart Niemeyer , The Political Science Reviewer: Vol. 31 (2002): A Symposium on Gerhart Niemeyer
- Nathan Pinkoski, Why Alasdair MacIntyre is not a Conservative Post-Liberal , The Political Science Reviewer: Vol. 43 No. 2 (2019): Symposium: The Missouri Compromise at 200
You may also start an advanced similarity search for this article.
Most read articles by the same author(s)
- Joseph M Knippenberg, From Kant to Marx , The Political Science Reviewer: Vol. 20 (1991): Reviews
- Peter I Minowitz, Machiavellianism Come of Age? Leo Strauss on Modernity and Economics , The Political Science Reviewer: Vol. 22 (1993): Essays
- Michael Davis, Seth Benardete’s Second Sailing , The Political Science Reviewer: Vol. 32 (2003): A Symposium on Bertrand de Jouvenel
- Stanley Rothman, Functionalism and its critics , The Political Science Reviewer: Vol. 1 (1971): Reviews
- Paul M Dowling, Richard H Cox, Herman Melville’s Civil War Lincolnian Prudence in Poetry , The Political Science Reviewer: Vol. 29 (2000): A Symposium on Herbert J Storing
- Louise Cowan, I’ll Take My Stand as Epic , The Political Science Reviewer: Vol. 30 (2001): Symposia on Kant Studies and on <em>I’ll Take My Stand</em>
- John C Caiazza, Political Dilemmas of Social Biology , The Political Science Reviewer: Vol. 34 (2005): Eric Voegelin’s <em>New Science of Politics</em>: A 50th Anniversary Symposium
- Mathew Manweller, Controlling the “Commanding Heights” of Political Science Education , The Political Science Reviewer: Vol. 38 (2009): A Symposium on Rémi Brague’s <em>The Law of God: The Philosophical History of an Idea</em>
- Michael Franz, Gnosticism and Spiritual Disorder in The Ecumenic Age , The Political Science Reviewer: Vol. 27 (1998): Eric Voegelin’s <em>The Ecumenic Age</em>: A Symposium
- Gregory Wolfe, Discerning the Spirits , The Political Science Reviewer: Vol. 31 (2002): A Symposium on Gerhart Niemeyer